Im voting QFG4.

As for phantasmagoria, its good I guess but Joe described it perfectly "What am I looking at?"

I vote for Phantasmagoria.

Phantasmagoria

I voted for Phantasmagoria in the last round, but this time I vote for Quest for Glory 4.

I like how the creatures break out of the frame, the colors remind me of Terry Pratchett's funny Discworld books and roleplaying games. The upper text makes me curious about the game. I haven't played either, and if I had to buy any of those two, I would definitely get that game on the left.

My vote is for Phantasmagoria too.

Phantasmagoria wins 7-5! And the last of the quest for glory series is out...

 Next match:

vote for colonels bequest

SQ3 is too busy

Colonels Bequest.

This one is really tough. Colonels bequest is more mysterious and elegant, you immediately get what the game is about…  SQ3 is more crowded as has been said  but its pure sierra energy and the shelf impact back in the day must have been big! 

 Voting SQ3

Colonels Bequest